Cartoons of prophet Mohamed
In Denmark
Benchekroun Karmi Loubna.
International Communication
DR. Mohamed Ibahrine
July 07th, 2008
September 30, 2005, this date will stay for ever in the memory of every single Muslims in the world. In this date, the daily newspaper Jyllands-Posten ("The
Jutland Post") published an article entitled "Muhammeds ansigt” ("The face of Muhammad") made by the creator Kurt Westergaard .In fact, according to the official website of CNN “
www.cnn.net “ this newspaper previously cited posted an article that consist of twelve cartoons (caricatures) which contain some that portrayed ridiculously the prophet Mohamed. Indeed, according to the official website of BBC “ www.bbc.net” “these cartoons were reported in
the Morgenavisen Jyllands-Posten (in english: The Morning Newspaper "The Jutland Post"), commonly shortened to Jyllands-Posten or JP which is a Danish daily broadsheet newspaper based in Viby, a suburb of Århus with a weekday circulation of approximately 150,000 copies; It is also the largest-selling newspaper in Denmark. Jyllands-Posten newspaper stated that this publication was an attempt to contribute to the debate regarding
criticism of Islam and
self-censorship”. The cartoons of prophet Mohamed published in Danish newspaper took great media space in diverse medium of media that have reached millions of people around the world. Each channel has broadcast that event differently according to diverse measures. BBC, CNN, and Al Jazeera are three major media power who’s transmission and interpretation concerning the event allowed to change many notions. There are some major factors that one should consider in order to understand any media comment made by a journalist about such events. In fact, one should always be aware of these three main points in order to evaluate comments made on television. First of all, you should be aware of the country or even the continent where the journalist comments were made about a given event. Second, the kind of relationship that the journalist has with this specific event. Finally, the weight of the media in the country where the comment about the event are made.
The first factor that one should consider is the location of the media that made the comment about the event. In fact, if the location of BBC and CNN are quiet similar while the one of Al Jazeera is quiet different. Indeed, the two channels cited first are located in developed countries while the second one is not. Moreover, the same conclusion emerges from the relationship of Al Jazeera with the religion of Islam set on some specific location such as the Middle East which is a close and significant relationship which means that the religion also could have an effect on the media. Furthermore, the media weight in different location is different. In fact, Media is considered to be the forth power in the West which is not the case in underdeveloped countries where it is measured to be in the development road and they are mainly controlled under the government.
For example, according to the official website of BBC The British Broadcasting Corporation, which is
usually known as the BBC was founded by John Reith in the United Kingdom and “it is the largest broadcasting corporation in the world in terms of audience numbers and of revenue. Moreover, British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) is the dominant broadcaster in the UK, operating several public terrestrial TV stations, cable and digital channels and a terrestrial radio network; it is availability sounds nationally and internationally.” (www.bbc.net )
Furthermore, according to the official website of CNN Cable News Network, commonly referred to by its acronym CNN is a major cable television network founded in 1980 by Ted Turner. “The network is now owned by Time Warner and it is a division of the Turner Broadcasting System. As one of the main headquarter in the United State, the CNN operates one of the top 24-hour news channels, reaching more than 92 million US homes. CNN also has an international division that keeps viewers informed in more than 200 countries and has 36 news bureaus around the world, including 10 in the US.” Away from the television, CNN operates a top ranked news Web site and offers syndicated news services and it is the one that introduced the idea of 24-hour television news coverage that perceived the notion of the term “The CNN effect”. (www.cnn.net)
Furthermore, Al Jazeera is a satellite Channel and the Arab world most professional news and information television channel. According to the official website of Al Jazeera “www.aljazeera.net” Located in Doha Qatar and financed by the state of Qatar, Al Jazeera (which means "the Arab peninsula") has been broadcasting since 1996 and is uniquely positioned to broadcast in the Arab world's point of view to the Western public. The Zogby international (US polling company) survey of May 2005 declared that “Al Jazeera seizing 51.7 percents of viewship in the Arab world of majority of respondents considering it is a primary source of information.” Moreover, Al Jazeera was mainly founded by Sheikh Hamad bin Thamer al-Thani. Actually, “Western media often pick up interviews and reports from Al Jazeera and rebroadcast the same news translated for their own viewers.” Moreover, Al Jazeera is a channel available worldwide especially to the Arab Muslims community since it’s a fully Arabic-speaking channels. Furthermore, “western leaders claim that Al Jazeera has an anti-US, anti-Israel bias, and a distinct affinity for Osama bin Laden and his Al Qaeda network.” ( www.aljazeera.net) Finally, Al Jazeera, based in Qatar, traditionally publishes information in Arabic for a predominately middle east viewers. But in order to provide to universal viewship, the agency created an English version of its content.
We can consider CNN and BBC are quiet similar in terms of same bases of point of view, but it differs in forms. BBC and CNN both of them are clearly defending the freedom of speech in Denmark. BBC has already broadcast the cartoons; however, CNN has chosen to not show the cartoons out of respect for Islam. The position of BBC seems stronger than CNN since BBC belongs to the British control that is located in Europe and thus Denmark is measured to be in the European circle.
The British Broadcasting Corporation, which is usually known as the BBC has covered the cartoons network of prophet Mohamed in different prospective. On one hand, BBC used international politics personalities in the world to portray the positive aspect of journalists. In other words, it justifies the cartoons made by the journalists. For instance, according to Flemming Rose, culture editor of Jyllands-Posten said that “in Demark we have a tradition of satire and humor and some cartoonists made satirical cartoons. We have done the same thing with Jesus Christ and other religions. That’s what we do with the royal family, politicians and other public figures. We were not treating Islam or the Prophet any differently from how we treat everybody else in Denmark.” Also, according to Karen Armstrong religious affairs commentator cited that “”we are seeing a clash of two different notions of what is sacred.” Through these two testimonials, it is enough clear to show that BBC tries to support the side of freedom of speech.
On the other hand, BBC claims also through one of its website what does the holly book of Islam “the Quran” says about that issue and what the position these cartoons according to the Islamic tradition are. Moreover, BBC responds to the first question by mentioning that there is not specific banning claim that states the prohibition of cartooning the prophet Mohamed “there is no specific, or explicit ban in the Koran on images of Allah or the prophet Mohamed – be they carved, painted or drawn.” Besides, BBC has interpreted one of the verse in the Koran “Allah is the originator of the heavens and the earth … there is nothing a likeness of Him. » which is an interpretation only given by Muslims since nothing explicitly is mentioned about the prohibition of cartooning prophet Mohamed.” Concerning the second question about the Muslim tradition, BBC reveals that “the reproduction of images of the Prophet, mainly produced in the 7th Century in Persia can be found and comments by mentioning that Islam is not really strict regarding this ban since it has been already done.”
Regarding Cable News Network or CNN, it has also clearly defended the freedom of press. In fact, CNN claims in one of its official website the cause that these cartoons have been reprinted as a cause of free speech. On one hand, CNN talks about another aspect of this event which is about the creator Kurt Westergaard and the difficulties that he faced from the Muslims communities. On the other hand, CNN publishes the statement of Paula Newton that stated the following: “the arrests reinforced growing fears in Europe that radical Islam was trying to suppress free speech” This statement shows that this event has contributed to the degradation of the Muslims picture worldwide. Besides, CNN publishes the commentary of Jihad Momeni, a former member of the Jordanian senate that stated the following: “who offend more Islam? A foreigner who endeavors to draw the prophet as described by his followers in the world, or a Muslims with an explosive belt who commits suicide in a wedding party in Amman or elsewhere?” this is a clear illustration of how CNN try to show that even in the Muslim Arab world it is considered that the action of cartoons seems normal.
Above and beyond, Al Jazeera broadcasting media has covered the cartoons of prophet Mohamed in Denmark differently from BBC and CNN. Furthermore, Al Jazeera stressed more of clarification of the event rather than seeking for reconciliation and its main aim was to provide the Arab world the maximum of information with a deep interpretation where it can reach everybody and can allow a better understanding of the event. Moreover, the great manifestation was a significant way that illustrates the violence response of the Muslims world to these cartoons. According to the official website of Al Jazeera cited that “the drawings sparked protests across the Muslims world, and in some places, including Iran, Syria, and Lebanon, the protests turned into attacks against Danish and other western diplomatic missions. In Afghanistan, nearly a dozen people were killed in protests”. On one hand, the media coverage of Al Jazeera raised the point of boycotting the Danish products and its financial losses. However, CNN and BBC discuss this point in surface during the coverage of the event as Al Jazeera mentioned in one of page of its official website that “consumer boycotts of Danish goods in Muslims countries in protest at publication of caricatures of the prophet Muhammad are costing Denmark’s companies millions, and has raised fears of irreparable damage to trade ties. From Havarti cheese to Lego, Danish products have been yanked off the shelves of stores in Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and other countries around the Middle East…”
On the other hand, al Jazeera has posted that the Danish newspaper presented the regret to the Muslims community about what have been written about the prophet Mohamed cartoons. However, BBC and CNN mentions that the Danish newspaper refuses to either express their regret or apologize toward the Islamic world “Denmark’s prime ministry has expressed regret over the offence caused, but has refused to apologize on behalf of the Danish daily Jylland –Posten, which first published the cartoons. The paper’s editor has apologized for offending Muslims…” Besides, al Jazeera has promoted the big initiative made by the international community by Muslims where fifty people were sent to the Denmark to promote the right explanation of Islam as a religion. This idea was a good way to clarify religious matter and to endorse the right approach of explanation of the holly book ‘Koran”. This is clearly showing the position of Al Jazeera as being in broadcasting in Muslim country.
Also, the Arab channel reports what Kofi Annan , the United Nation secretary-general think about this issue, whereas the two others channels BBC and CNN did not mention since it affects negatively Danish actions “the freedom of the press should not be an excuse for insulting religions and expressed concern about the controversy over a Danish newspaper’s publication of cartoons of the prophet Muhammad”. Also, Al Jazeera posted the testimonial run by France’s Carrefour in Europe said that “in solidarity with Muslims, we will not offer Danish products.”
As observed, these three kinds of media CNN, BCC, and Al Jazeera treated the media coverage of this event in a different way. Both CNN and BBC tried to justify the cartoons made by Denmark by the freedom of press that country have. However, Al Jazeera argues that it believes that freedom of press should exist but although it should have some limits such us the criticizing of any religions. As I mentioned before, these difference of reporting events is due to many factors: CNN and BBC are quiet different from al Jazeera since their location and the religion relationship. Al Jazeera is located in Arab country Qatar that adopts Islam as a religion which explains the positive side that this channel holds.
Finally, CNN and BBC are so related channels, but they differ in forms. They are dominating the western world since BBC is located in Great Britain and CNN is the united state. They are grouping both the US part and also the European circle. Both of them they are defending the right of freedom of press. On the other hand, in the years since its launch, al Jazeera has not only changed the Arab perception of the small screen but it has known a noticeable way of how Arab and Muslims can receive the information.
When I have chosen the cartoons theme I thought that it was a subject that seems like others. However, it is measured to be among the most difficult writing subject since religion is a very sensitive topic and it is hard to talk about in an objective way. In order to understand neutrally the point of view of each broadcasting channels:
-You should be able to read between lines.
- You should be located where the event happened,
-Understanding the culture of others.
-And finally understanding conflict of interest.
In the case of our topic, we are in front of a comparison of an event between two opposed civilizations: the Western civilization and the Arab one. All these three channels CNN, BBC, and al Jazeera are considered to be a credible source.
References:
www.bbc.netwww.cnn.netwww.aljazeera.net